One yr after passage, New York Metropolis’s unprecedented short-term rental laws have did not ship on their promise to fight the housing disaster. Within the wake of stringent measures, customers are as an alternative dealing with all-time excessive resort costs and residents dealing with all-time excessive rents.
New knowledge underscores the results of Native Legislation 18 (LL18), an outlier on the subject of short-term rental laws.
A dearer vacation spot for customers
Within the yr since these guidelines took impact, there have been predictable outcomes, together with an increase in resort costs, which dangers pricing out on a regular basis folks hoping to journey to New York Metropolis.
The typical resort costs in New York rose 7.4 p.c in 12 months1, in contrast with an solely 2.1 p.c enhance, nationally, based on knowledge from CoStar.
Regardless of the regulation’s promise, rents rise and emptiness charges keep stagnant
Legislators claimed LL18 would defend inexpensive housing but an overwhelming body of evidence from the previous yr reveals this method has not delivered on that promise. Alicia Glenn, the previous NYC deputy mayor for housing underneath Mayor Invoice de Blasio, went as far as to say that she by no means noticed knowledge exhibiting that short-term leases have been affecting the housing disaster in a major means.
Insights one yr later, show that time:
Lease in New York Metropolis continues to rise: Regulators promised that banning Airbnb in New York Metropolis would unlock housing. As a substitute, lease climbed 3.4 p.c throughout the first 11 months of the regulation, based on StreetEasy, suggesting that different elements are driving up lease costs. In truth, the median asking value of lease downtown Manhattan over the previous yr reached a peak of $5,000 for the primary time in historical past.
Emptiness ranges stay unchanged: Emptiness charges for residences in New York Metropolis have remained just about unchanged (at 3.4 p.c) because the regulation took impact, based on Apartment List.
New York stays out of step with different main cities: Whereas rents might have cooled nationally, the rise in New York rents NYC’s lease enhance because the regulation took impact continues to outpace close by cities like Boston, Chicago and Washington, D.C. In the meantime, New York Metropolis’s emptiness charges additionally proceed to considerably lag behind Chicago, Boston and Washington, D.C.
“New York Metropolis’s short-term rental laws have backfired—disproportionately impacting outer borough communities, driving up journey prices, and doing nothing to resolve the housing disaster. As a substitute of bettering affordability, these laws have priced out on a regular basis customers and left former hosts struggling to make ends meet.”
Theo Yedinsky, VP, Public Coverage at Airbnb
The outer boroughs are left with nearly no lodging choices
With most of New York’s accommodations clustered in midtown Manhattan, LL18 significantly reduced out there lodging within the outer boroughs, condensing vacationers, limiting the place they keep, and the place and the way they spend.
Airbnb listings in a lot of town served areas with out resort choices. Previous to LL18, Airbnb listings have been extra geographically dispersed throughout all 5 boroughs in comparison with accommodations with fewer than half of the total Airbnb listings in Manhattan, whereas Brooklyn and Queens have been dwelling to 37 p.c and 13 p.c of Airbnb listings, respectively.
In 2023, the everyday Airbnb visitor in New York Metropolis spent a median of roughly $260 per day, with greater than a 3rd of spending close to their itemizing2. A scarcity of accessible short-term rental lodging disproportionately hurts the outer boroughs, resulting in fewer stays and fewer spending exterior Manhattan.
Organizations just like the Brooklyn Chamber of Commerce have sounded the alarm concerning the regulation’s disparate impacts. In a metropolis the place the price of residing continues to climb, the lack of revenue has devastated those that depend on home-sharing to cowl important bills and small companies reliant on tourism {dollars}.
“The fact has been a major setback for Brooklyn’s tourism and native economic system, with out the corresponding promised enhance in rental housing availability the federal government hoped for. We hope the Metropolis Council rigorously revisits the regulation to help the native owners and financial growth of communities within the outer boroughs.”
Randy Friends, President and CEO, Brooklyn Chamber of Commerce, in an op-ed within the Brooklyn Paper
These considerations have been echoed by the Dominican American Chamber of Commerce.
“Native Legislation 18 has favored massive companies on the expense of middle-class residents and native small companies. With lease costs surging and lots of households counting on short-term leases for supplemental revenue, the regulation has created monetary pressure for particular person hosts and a decline in income for native companies that thrive on tourism.”
Manuel Lebron, CEO and Founder, Dominican American Chamber of Commerce
Another path ahead: Re-evaluating LL18
Even the invoice sponsor, former council member Ben Kallos, said that single households who lease one house shouldn’t be “frightened.” One yr later, that couldn’t be farther from the reality. The answer to fixing LL18 lies in a extra balanced method that acknowledges the worth of short-term leases whereas addressing one of many root causes of housing affordability – constructing extra properties.
“It’s time for New York Metropolis to re-evaluate LL18 and contemplate amendments that will at a minimal, permit owners to as soon as once more host friends. By rolling again elements of the regulation, town can enhance the provision of lodging for customers, help resident hosts, and revitalize native companies that rely on tourism {dollars}. A extra sustainable, smart and equitable mannequin advantages residents, guests, and the broader group – making certain that laws help, reasonably than stifle, group and financial development.”
Theo Yedinsky, VP, Public Coverage at Airbnb
Trending Merchandise
